Customs · Import valuation

First Sale Rule for Imports: How It Works in 2026

First sale valuation needs a documented qualifying earlier sale. Have your broker or customs counsel review the transaction chain before using a factory-to-middleman price.

By ForwarderOneNovember 22, 20265 min read
Quick answer First sale valuation needs a documented qualifying earlier sale. Have your broker or customs counsel review the transaction chain before using a factory-to-middleman price.

What the first sale rule means in plain terms

U.S. customs duty is usually charged on the “transaction value”: the price actually paid or payable for the goods, plus certain add-ons such as commissions, packing, royalties and license fees. The U.S. International Trade Commission explains that when goods are sold more than once before importation, the first sale rule lets an importer in certain circumstances use the price from the first or earlier sale as the customs value, as long as that sale can be documented as a sale for export to the United States and all other Customs requirements are met.

Here is the standard illustration. CNBC described a U.S. retailer buying a T-shirt for $10 from a Hong Kong vendor, who bought it from a Chinese manufacturer for $5. Under the rule, the retailer can pay duty on $5.

Two-tier T-shirt sale and duty value

The evidence CBP expects

A qualifying earlier transaction must be a bona fide sale for export to the United States, with an acceptable transaction value and required statutory additions. The importer must document the roles and transactions throughout the chain. CBP ruling H322425 explains the evidence and arm’s-length sale standard.

Related parties do not automatically disqualify a sale. Their relationship and its effect on price require additional analysis under the valuation rules. A sourcing agent’s service invoice alone does not establish an earlier sale of the goods.

A worked example with duty math

Say you import 1,000 units of a product from a trading company that buys from a factory. This is an illustration with a made-up rate, not a quote.

Without first sale With first sale
Value used for duty per unit $10.00 (price you paid) $5.00 (factory’s price)
Value for 1,000 units $10,000 $5,000
Duty at an assumed 25% rate $2,500 $1,250
Difference $1,250 saved

The illustrative saving depends on the accepted customs value and applicable duty rate. Statutory additions and fee minimums or maximums can change the final result; compare a broker’s calculation for the actual entry.

One point trips up first-timers. The earlier price is not simply “the factory price you were quoted”. The first sale must be a real, completed sale between the factory and the middleman, with the middleman taking title. Statutory additions such as commissions or packing costs still have to be accounted for. Tuttle Law notes you must tell CBP about any statutory additions and their amounts.

The paper trail CBP expects

The importer carries the burden of proof. In a ruling reported by International Trade Today in January 2026 (HQ H337689), CBP said the importer must provide a “complete paper trail” showing the structure of the entire transaction. That includes purchase orders, invoices, proof of payment and contracts. CBP decides case by case whether a sale is bona fide, looking at questions such as who assumed the risk of loss and who acquired title.

An earlier CBP ruling (HQ H246654) makes the same point from the other side. CBP presumes transaction value is the price the importer paid, and you rebut that presumption with complete documentation of every relevant transaction and the relationships between the parties.

In practice, for every shipment you would want to hold:

  • The factory’s invoice to the middleman, and the middleman’s invoice to you, kept as two separate documents.
  • Purchase orders at each level that show the goods were ordered for the U.S.
  • Proof the middleman paid the factory, and that you paid the middleman.
  • Contracts or terms showing who owns the goods and who carries risk at each step.
  • Evidence of the parties’ relationships and support for an acceptable arm’s-length price.

The General Notice T.D. 96-87 (January 1997) sets this expectation. If you cannot produce the evidence, the earlier sale cannot be the basis of your value. Your commercial invoice also has to be right at the entry stage, so our guide to commercial invoice requirements under 19 CFR §141.86 is a useful checklist to share with suppliers.

Entry and recordkeeping

Coordinate the declared value and supporting records with your customs broker before filing. Do not rely on the old temporary first-sale declaration requirement: CBP’s 2009 notice states that the one-year declaration requirement expired on August 19, 2009. The obligation to support the value used for an entry remains.

Does first sale fit a small Amazon seller?

It may fit a documented multi-tier buying chain where a trading company genuinely purchases and resells the goods. Buying directly from a factory gives you no earlier sale in that chain. Before changing purchasing arrangements, have a licensed customs broker or customs attorney review title, risk, export intent, price and records.

First sale is a valuation question, separate from the Incoterm used for transport. A DDP quote does not itself establish that a shipment qualifies.

What is happening with the rule in 2026

The introduced text of S. 3841, the Last Sale Valuation Act of 2026, proposes a change to customs valuation. Its introduction is not enactment. Check the current legislative record and applicable customs guidance with your adviser before relying on a sourcing structure.

Where duties stack up on top of valuation

Valuation is one input. The duty rate then depends on your product’s classification and where it comes from. For China-origin goods, additional tariffs can apply on top of the base rate, so see our explainers on Section 301 tariffs and Section 232 tariffs and DDP steps. Our overview of customs valuation for U.S. importers covers the transaction value basics that first sale builds on.

A correct declared value is the foundation. If the value is wrong, whether too high or unsupported, every duty calculated from it is wrong too.

Documents to get right whatever route you take

Whether or not you ever use first sale, these habits protect you:

  1. Ask your supplier for itemized commercial invoices that match what is in the box, with real unit prices.
  2. Keep purchase orders and payment proof together for every shipment, since CBP can ask for them.
  3. Know who your supplier is. A factory, a trading company and a sourcing agent are different things in a customs file.
  4. Record who owns the goods and who bears risk at each stage. CBP looks at both.
  5. Keep records organized by entry, so an audit question can be answered quickly.

FAQ

Is the first sale rule the same as the wash sale rule?

No. First sale concerns customs valuation of imported goods. The wash sale rule concerns income tax treatment of certain securities transactions.

Can I use a first sale value for imports in 2026?

A qualifying earlier sale may support transaction value when all customs requirements are met. Review the transaction chain, current law and supporting evidence with your broker or customs counsel.

Can I use first sale if I buy directly from a factory?

A direct factory purchase has no earlier factory-to-middleman sale in that chain. You cannot substitute an unsupported lower factory cost for the price actually paid.

What documents does CBP want to see for a first sale claim?

Keep purchase orders, invoices, payments, contracts and evidence of export intent, title, risk and party relationships for the whole transaction chain. Your broker or customs counsel can assess the evidence.

Prepare your customs paperwork

Share your shipment details and documentation so ForwarderOne can coordinate freight, customs clearance and delivery.

Explore Amazon FBA shippingPlan DDP shipping